I can totally understand your point. I think there's as much diversity among us as audience members as there is among us as dancers--we all watch for different reasons, with different likes and dislikes, all that stuff. At this point in my dance....oh, lord, the only word that comes to mind is the oh so cheesy "journey"; forgive me. ;-) At this point in my dance journey, not even two years in, I'm still fresh enough not to get too bored by simplicity, and I value the opportunity to watch a dance where I can see each move on its own.
That being said, I too *far* prefer a more dynamic dance, more interaction between dancers, more interesting usage of the stage space. However, being in a small town and not getting to see much in the way of live dancing often, I'm delighted with all sorts of performances. The only ones I really don't enjoy are ones where the troupe obviously didn't rehearse and is tense about it, or soloists who project arrogance, but don't have the mad dance skillz to back it up. (I don't much enjoy the arrogant posturing in any case, but I'll overlook it for a truly excellent dancer.)
My two cents. :-) But I don't see any reason for you to be unpopular for having an opinion, and I think you expressed it very very well. :-)